Key takeaways: Before December 31, review employee and employer records, reconcile wages and payroll taxes, check withholding and deductions, capture bonuses and taxable benefits, and confirm W-2 reporting details. Assign final payroll and filing responsibilities now. December preparation helps you resolve errors before year-end forms are issued and early-2027 filing deadlines arrive.
Your last regular payroll run may leave several year-end questions unanswered. Did an employee move? Were bonuses paid outside the usual payroll process? Did a benefits adjustment reach the person preparing W-2s?
Year-end payroll is the process of reconciling a calendar year’s employee pay, withholding, benefits, and employer tax records before completing annual reporting. Start the review in November so December has room for corrections, approvals, and funding.
Use this payroll year end checklist to assign each review to a person, record what they checked, and track unresolved items. For Utah employers, the review should include state withholding records alongside federal payroll tax compliance.
Are employee names, Social Security numbers, and addresses correct?
Verify employee identity and delivery information before preparing year-end forms. Include everyone paid during 2026, including employees who have left the business.
Ask employees to review their information through a secure process. Compare payroll records with appropriate source records, and investigate mismatches rather than guessing. Check mailing addresses, name changes, and access to electronic documents.
For example, a former employee may have moved after their final paycheck. Their wages can be correct while their W-2 delivery information is outdated. Make record verification a separate task from checking the dollar amounts.
Finish this check: Keep a dated record of the review and route sensitive corrections through your secure payroll channel. Don’t collect Social Security numbers through a shared spreadsheet or ordinary email.
Do employer accounts and work locations match your business?
Confirm the legal business name, federal employer identification number, and state payroll account information used for reporting. Review where employees actually worked during the year, especially if your team includes remote workers.
An employee’s home address and work location may create different questions. Give your payroll professional the relevant dates and locations so they can assess registration, withholding, and unemployment reporting requirements.
Also confirm that authorized staff can access tax accounts and receive agency correspondence. A login tied only to a departed employee can delay a correction when time is short.
Finish this check: Create a list of active payroll jurisdictions and account owners. Resolve unclear locations with your adviser before annual reports are finalized.
Does your year-end payroll reconcile with the books?
Compare year-to-date payroll reports with your accounting records, filed quarterly returns, and payment confirmations. Investigate differences before using those totals to prepare W-2s.
Payroll reconciliation means comparing related payroll records and explaining or correcting differences between them. Review gross pay, taxable wage categories, employee withholding, employer payroll taxes, and amounts still payable.
Don’t expect every wage total to be identical. Different tax treatments can create legitimate differences between gross pay, federal taxable wages, and Social Security or Medicare wages. Keep an explanation for each difference.
If you switched payroll providers during 2026, confirm that prior-provider balances were imported accurately. Compare the combined annual totals with the original reports; a clean final-quarter report doesn’t prove the full year is complete.
Finish this check: Maintain an exception list showing the amount, cause, correction, and person responsible for each unresolved difference.

Are withholding elections and payroll settings current?
Review the withholding instructions on file and confirm that payroll applies them correctly. Invite employees to review their elections when their circumstances change, while leaving personal tax decisions to employees and their tax advisers.
The IRS explains in Publication 15, Employer’s Tax Guide that an existing Form W-4 generally remains in effect until replaced. A new calendar year doesn’t automatically require every employee to submit a new form.
Check for unprocessed employee requests, incorrect effective dates, and settings carried over during a system change. Ask your payroll professional about special requirements for employees claiming exemption from withholding.
Finish this check: Confirm which elections are active. Separate a prospective withholding change from any correction needed for an earlier processing error.
Have bonuses and off-cycle payments reached payroll?
Give payroll a complete record of bonuses, commissions, manual checks, and other compensation paid outside the regular run. Confirm the payment date, pay type, and tax treatment before approving final processing.
Supplemental wages are compensation paid in addition to regular wages, such as bonuses or commissions. Their withholding treatment depends on the circumstances; don’t assume every bonus uses the same calculation.
A payment described as a “net bonus” also needs clarification: does the employer intend a specific take-home amount, and has the additional tax cost been approved? Send those instructions before processing begins.
For ordinary wage reporting, the pay date generally determines the W-2 year. The IRS’s 2026 W-2 instructions illustrate that December work paid in January belongs on the following year’s W-2.
Finish this check: Reconcile off-cycle payments with the payroll register and confirm the actual payment dates.
Have benefits and taxable fringe items been reviewed?
Collect benefit information that may need to be included in wages or reported on year-end forms. Ask for the information early enough to evaluate it before the final payroll adjustments are approved.
A fringe benefit is compensation provided through a benefit or service beyond regular pay. Its tax treatment depends on the benefit and applicable rules.
Items to flag for professional review include personal use of an employer vehicle, gift cards, group-term life insurance, and health insurance paid for certain S corporation shareholders. Reimbursements may also need review if their documentation or treatment is unclear.
According to IRS Publication 15-B, Employer’s Tax Guide to Fringe Benefits, fringe benefits are generally taxable unless a specific exclusion applies. Different benefits can have different valuation and reporting rules.
Finish this check: Obtain the benefit description, supporting amount, and relevant dates. Have payroll or your tax adviser determine the treatment rather than assigning all benefits one earnings code.
Do deductions match employee elections and plan records?
Compare payroll deductions with the elections, authorizations, and plan records that support them. Review both employee deductions and applicable employer contributions.
Check retirement contributions, health coverage deductions, health savings account contributions, garnishments, and other recurring items. Use the limits and rules applicable to the specific plan and employee; don’t assume one limit fits everyone.
Also compare amounts withheld with amounts remitted. A deduction shown correctly on a pay statement still needs to reach the appropriate plan or recipient on time. Don’t postpone a required remittance until the year-end review.
Finish this check: Refer discrepancies to the plan administrator or payroll professional promptly. Document any correction instructions and verify the resulting payroll entry.
Are payroll tax deposits and agency notices accounted for?
Match tax liabilities with deposit confirmations and investigate outstanding notices. Keep filing a return and paying the tax as separate checklist items.
The IRS’s employment tax due-date guidance distinguishes deposit schedules from return deadlines. Waiting for an annual or quarterly filing date can leave a deposit overdue.
Review federal, Utah, and other applicable state records. Where a notice shows an apparent balance, compare the agency’s period and account number with your own records before paying again.
If a payroll provider handles tax payments, obtain confirmations and clarify who will investigate any discrepancy. PayrollOne’s payroll services include payroll tax filing and compliance support; confirm the responsibilities that apply to your account.
Finish this check: Record the status of each notice, response deadline, assigned owner, and proof of resolution.

Is W-2 preparation ready for the 2026 reporting requirements?
Review a preliminary W-2 report before final forms are issued. Check employee details, wage categories, withholding, benefit codes, and state information against the supporting payroll records.
The IRS’s 2026 W-2 instructions introduce code TP for reported cash tips, code TT for qualified overtime compensation, and box 14b for Treasury Tipped Occupation Codes. Confirm that your system captures the applicable information. Qualified overtime isn’t necessarily the entire overtime payment, and the deduction doesn’t generally eliminate payroll withholding.
For Utah payroll, the Utah State Tax Commission’s employer withholding guidance requires an annual reconciliation with the fourth-quarter return or applicable annual return. Confirm the electronic TC-941E and applicable W-2 and 1099 submissions needed for your account.
Finish this check: Confirm who prepares federal and state forms, how employees will receive them, and how errors will be corrected. Review contractor reporting separately rather than treating contractors as employees.
Who owns final payroll cutoffs and the filing calendar?
Set internal deadlines with your payroll provider and assign an owner to every remaining task. Allow time for funding, bank holidays, approvals, and corrections.
Use the calendar below as a planning framework. Your provider’s processing cutoffs may be earlier than a tax deadline.
| When | Employer review or action | Evidence to keep |
|---|---|---|
| November | Verify records, identify discrepancies, request benefit details | Assigned checklist and exception list |
| Before the provider’s final adjustment cutoff | Approve bonuses, benefit entries, and corrections | Written approvals and final input records |
| Before December 31, 2026 | Confirm final pay dates, funding, and unresolved items | Payroll calendar and funding confirmation |
| Before forms are issued | Review annual totals and preliminary W-2 information | Reconciliation and approval record |
| February 1, 2027 | Generally furnish 2026 W-2s to employees and file them with the Social Security Administration | Delivery and filing confirmations |
| Throughout the close | Follow each applicable deposit and return deadline | Agency calendar and acceptance records |
The W-2 deadline above comes from the IRS’s 2026 instructions. It doesn’t replace separate federal or state payment and filing schedules.
Finish this check: Name a backup approver and agree on how payroll support will handle a late discovery. A deadline is useful only when someone owns the work.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. When should an employer start year-end payroll preparation?
Start in November so there’s time to verify employee records, reconcile totals, and collect benefit information. Complete adjustments by your payroll provider’s applicable cutoff, which may be earlier than December 31.
2. Do all payroll tax filings have to be completed by December 31?
No. December 31 closes the calendar year, but annual forms and some returns are due afterward. Tax deposits follow separate schedules, so use a calendar that lists each obligation individually.
3. When are 2026 W-2s due?
Employers generally must furnish 2026 W-2s to employees and file them with the Social Security Administration by February 1, 2027. Prepare and review the information before that deadline.
4. What extra year-end payroll review should Utah employers complete?
Review Utah withholding totals and the annual reconciliation requirements alongside federal reporting. Include other jurisdictions if employees worked outside Utah, and confirm the applicable accounts and filing responsibilities with your payroll professional.
5. Can a payroll provider handle the entire year-end review?
A provider can handle the tasks included in your service agreement, but employers still need to supply accurate records and approve adjustments. Confirm who owns benefits information, manual payments, employee changes, tax notices, and final filing review.
Bring your open items to PayrollOne before the final payroll rush. Contact PayrollOne to review year-end payroll support, processing cutoffs, and filing responsibilities for your business. You can also read the payroll FAQs before the conversation.
This article is general information, not tax, accounting, legal, or HR advice. Rules change and depend on your circumstances; consult a qualified tax or employment professional about your specific situation.
Author Bio
Taylor Bennett oversees PayrollOne. Drawing on his accounting and business experience, he focuses on helping employers connect payroll with accurate financial records, organized processes and practical business decisions. His payroll guidance emphasizes clear responsibilities, reliable reporting and preparation for year-end requirements.
Received a Payroll Tax Notice? What to Do Next | PayrollOne
November 19, 2026[…] the immediate issue is addressed, use the year-end payroll checklist to review reconciliations, deposits, and filing ownership before annual […]